Should women have the right to vote? Should they work outside the home? Are they as smart as men? For years, those questions found audiences primarily in the extreme online world of the “manosphere,” where influencers get clicks by answering: “no.” Today, their formerly fringe ideas have escaped the dark recesses of social media and are gaining support in the real world, including (but not only) at elite religious and conservative colleges.
At Hillsdale, a selective, conservative liberal arts college in Michigan, a student wrote in the campus newspaper, “Three ugly words have wormed their way through campus, into Saturday-night conversations, laughter in the hallways and serious discussions: Repeal the 19th.” Another student noted that she had “heard several women seriously argue that women are intellectually and creatively deficient compared to men.”
Abigail Favale, a professor at the University of Notre Dame, recently told me that she has also seen “a real turn toward rigid gender roles and hierarchy” on campus, as increasing numbers of female students feel pressured by their peers and social media to picture themselves primarily as wives and mothers after graduation. Dr. Favale said she encountered some young women in “a state of dissonance,” torn between this view of strict gender roles and their own professional or academic goals.
Conservative think tanks, elected officials and the Republican Party itself have all struggled to offer a comprehensive response to the rise of this ideology, which I’ll call radical anti-feminism. Politicians have refused to acknowledge just how troubling these ideas are; some, such as Pete Hegseth, are elevating them. As a conservative myself, the most charitable interpretation I can think of for the general silence is that leaders are afraid that acknowledging such radical ideas, even to counter them, will offer them legitimacy. But some may believe that it’s in their interest to play footsie with this movement to woo more alienated young men to the Republican camp.
That is a serious moral and strategic error. Gen Z men swung almost 40 percentage points toward Democrats in the 2026 midterm elections, according to preliminary data from Times Voter Trends. There is no evidence that antifeminist rhetoric is capable of igniting sustained or pragmatic political engagement. Republicans also lost a 10-point advantage among white women and saw young women in general swing 28 points to the left, meaning the party has a lot of ground to make up with female voters if it hopes for success in the next presidential and congressional elections.
Combating radical antifeminism is not only good politics — it is the right thing to do. But tackling the problem requires explicitly recognizing its existence, offering a vigorous and vibrant counterargument and distinguishing it from other, legitimate debates over gender.
Conservatives get a lot right in our conversations about men and women. Biological differences between the sexes (especially concerning pregnancy and childbirth) are acknowledged, as are the real and sometimes irreconcilable tensions between work and home life. The right also tends to take seriously the unique problems facing boys and men right now: lower educational attainment, trouble finding good jobs, substance abuse problems and increased social alienation. I understand why young men who are struggling might be drawn to a vision of the world where there is a clear villain to blame.
A healthy conservatism leaves a lot of room for debate over what exactly is at the root of young men’s troubles and how best to help them. The conservative writer Helen Andrews, for example, has proposed that when women entered fields like academia and journalism in large numbers, they brought “feminine patterns of behavior” with them, alienating and disadvantaging men. I have repeatedly written in opposition to this “great feminization” thesis but it’s fair game for discussion.
But the ideas that women should not have the right to vote, that women are intellectually inferior to men, that women should not work? None of those would solve young men’s problems. And if conservatives treat those ideas as fodder for legitimate debate, it would only backfire on them and the young men they want to help.
Our economy and government cannot function without the extensive participation of American women. This should go without saying in 2026. As the midterm elections helped demonstrate, anyone who tries to turn that train around is going to get flattened.
What’s more, while radical antifeminists may pitch their philosophy as “traditional,” their ideas are far from it. My own great-great-grandmother worked as a clerk in the early 20th century after her husband died, so she could feed their young children. My great-grandmother, my grandmother, my mother and I have all worked, each of us scaling our careers up and down around family needs at times. Radical antifeminists ignore this reality, imagining an idealized past that never existed. (It should tell us something that a substantial amount of the visual imagery swirling around this phenomenon is A.I. generated.)
Tacitly tolerating this ideology is also backfiring on a social level. For mainstream conservatives who want young men and women to thrive, find meaning in life and build families, consider this: Radical antifeminism is making it difficult for some young conservatives in college to date. I have heard repeatedly about how its spread on campuses is killing off potential romances, as both sexes are increasingly suspicious of each other. Women don’t want to date men who see them as “lesser,” while men have been taught by the “manosphere” that women are untrustworthy and out to use them for money.
Without exaggerating its spread or influence, the trend is real and growing. But it also offers an opportunity for conservatives to come together around an agenda that actually does address the problems young men and women face. That will involve a real, substantive, even messy debate. But stripping women of the right to vote should not be on the table, nor should be relegating women to the kitchen. Those on the right contemplating a post-Trump future in 2028 and beyond should not want a movement in which the elite of the next generation is formed, even if only partially or indirectly, by misogyny. Conservatives must provide a better vision for the roles of young men and women — one that seeks out and inspires the best in both sexes.
