As the first leader of the New York Federal Reserve, Benjamin Strong Jr. was an unusually powerful banker. He had clear ideas about how the Fed should manage economic downturns, and close relationships with European central bankers. But in October 1928, he died after having surgery for an intestinal abscess. When Wall Street collapsed a year later, Strong’s absence left a paralyzed, divided Federal Reserve, transforming an ordinary stock market crash into a historic catastrophe, and paving the way for World War II.
Ken Burns: The Great Depression is the greatest economic cataclysm in the history of the world. When Franklin Roosevelt was talking to his economist, he said, “Was there any precedent?” And they said, “Yes, the Dark Ages, which lasted 400 years.”
Goldin: To attach it to a date, I would say the death of Benjamin Strong, which created the power vacuum that set off the Great Depression, which led to years of bread lines in the U.S. and left a legacy of social insurance. America became a more modern economy because of it. It also destabilized much of Europe and led to World War II.
Rick Perlstein: The Great Depression is also kind of the birth of the modern socialist democratic idea that rights can’t be fully exercised unless there’s a floor beneath which nobody can fall. And the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy was when this idea was suspended for the duration — and was arguably the birth date of global populism.
Goldin: Because of what we learned in the 1920s, we didn’t have a Great Depression in 2008-2009. The ghost of Benjamin Strong taught Geithner and Bernanke a lesson, and prevented disaster.
Wang: May I speak against the Great Depression? I am not sure that the ripple effects of the Great Depression went much beyond South America and Europe. So first, it may be a little bit too domestic-focused, and second, you know, it is not that extraordinary.
Henry Louis Gates Jr.: There was actually another Great Depression in 1873. It was called the Great Depression until 1929, when the greater depression supplanted it.
Perlstein: There were a lot of depressions until the Great Depression, until we figured out how to stop them, until we took away the figuring-out-how-to-stop them.
