Without a treaty, India would have no formal commitment to release water at regular intervals, potentially affecting Bangladesh’s agriculture, economy and ecology, Manjur said.
A file photo of Farakka Barrage.Photo: Collected
“>
A file photo of Farakka Barrage.Photo: Collected
India and Bangladesh should renew the Ganges Water Treaty for another three to five years as there is insufficient time to negotiate a revised agreement before the existing 30-year treaty expires next month, a Bangladeshi river expert has said, reports The Hindu.
Manjur Ahmed Chowdhury, former chairman of the National River Conservation Commission, said yesterday (15 November) that a temporary renewal was the most realistic option, provided the political leadership of both countries gave the necessary clearance.
“Four weeks is not sufficient for revising the old Ganges Water Treaty, as river water treaties require more time to finalise. But having a bad treaty is also better than not having any treaty at all. We can at least opt for a renewal of the treaty for three to five years, if the political leaderships of both sides give the green signal,” he said.
Chowdhury warned that the absence of an agreement could create serious problems for Bangladesh ahead of the agricultural season beginning in February, when the country’s dependence on Ganges water increases.
Without a treaty, India would have no formal commitment to release water at regular intervals, potentially affecting Bangladesh’s agriculture, economy and ecology, he said.
The Ganges Water Treaty was signed in December 1996 by former Indian prime minister H D Deve Gowda and the then Bangladesh prime minister Sheikh Hasina for a period of 30 years.
Before the agreement, Bangladesh faced uncertainty over Ganges water supplies for eight years between 1988 and 1996. The treaty introduced a predictable water-sharing arrangement, which benefited Bangladesh, Chowdhury said.
Under the agreement, water at the Farakka Barrage is shared between the two countries in 10-day periods from 1 January to 31 May each year, based on a formula outlined in its first annexure.
The formula provides for an equal 50:50 division when the available water flow at Farakka is 70,000 cusecs or less. It also specifies sharing arrangements for flows between 70,000 and 75,000 cusecs and those exceeding 75,000 cusecs.
Chowdhury said Bangladesh would struggle to secure its rightful share of Ganges water without a legally and diplomatically binding agreement.
“During the Ershad years, we suffered from this lack of predictability, and reverting to that era will be a setback,” he said, referring to the period when HM Ershad was president from 1983 to 1990.
He also criticised the government’s handling of foreign policy, saying water-sharing issues required effective diplomatic engagement with India.
“The foreign policy of the government has become unhinged from real requirements. At the moment, there is an urgent need for agreement between the political leaderships of Bangladesh and India to ensure the Ganges Water Treaty remains on track,” he said.
Chowdhury said the treaty should have been revised to address issues such as sedimentation and changes in the river over the past three decades.
However, a lack of meetings in recent months had prevented progress on the revisions, while the Joint River Commission had remained weak in carrying out its responsibilities, he said.
“I am still hopeful that, at least by the first week of December, the two sides will act to save the treaty. But that would have to be a dramatic development,” he added.
