The Day America Made a Promise
Feb. 3, 1870: The 15th Amendment is ratified.
In early 1869, the United States Senate voted to send the 15th Amendment to the states for ratification. It was the last of the Reconstruction amendments, the three additions made to the Constitution following the Civil War that profoundly changed American society. The 13th Amendment abolished slavery; the 14th established birthright citizenship and protected due process. Now, after months of debate, Congress had agreed to protect voting rights for Black men.
The path to reach the required three-fourths threshold of state approval took the better part of the next year, but when the amendment was finally certified, thanks to Iowa, The Times noted the occasion a few pages inside the paper the next day. It was, the article said, “the perfect fruit of our great national labor.”
March 31, 1870
Crowning the Edifice
At last the goal is reached, and the political struggle of a century is happily ended.
For months, there were celebrations all over the country: Newly enfranchised Black Americans marched through Union Square in New York City, saluting a statue of George Washington. In Baltimore, Frederick Douglass joined a parade attended by thousands, rejoicing.
The historian Eric Foner has called the Reconstruction amendments the country’s “second founding,” which laid the groundwork for the far more diverse country we live in today, with citizens drawn from every corner of the world, and ensured that all of those citizens would have a political voice.
Though women would have to wait another 50 years for the right to vote, the 15th Amendment was a bold promise that American democracy could be for everyone. Our panelists argued that this made it influential throughout the world.
Marie Arana: The 15th Amendment was super important internationally, because it became understood that you could write these human rights into a foundational text. In different colonial spots that were suddenly independent, they began to actually imitate the American Constitution, and particularly the 15th Amendment.
Christopher Caldwell: People all around the world today, when they try to manage minority rights, do it with these ideas. There’s something about the American way of doing this. It has created a template for rights. It was the ideological engine the United States used to justify itself through its century and a half as Top Nation.
Before settling on the 15th, our panel argued over which of the three amendments was the most significant.
Nell Irvin Painter: All three amendments are fundamental to American citizenship, but over time, the 15th has become the most consequential on account of its recognition of the fundamental importance, the power of the right to vote.
Henry Louis Gates Jr.: What is “Birth of a Nation” about? The right of Black men to vote.
Painter: Not voting left citizens vulnerable to police violence and without access to protections through the legal system. Disfranchisement meant more than just not being able to elect your representatives. They couldn’t become firemen and policemen and schoolteachers, because those were patronage jobs. You can only get a patronage job if you’re a voter. And when Black people moved to the North and to the West and started being voters, then they got on the class escalator of regular paychecks.
John Ganz: But the concept of citizenship that came out of the 14th Amendment is the one that’s being struggled over today.
Caldwell: Yes, it redefines what it means to belong to a country. You’re born here. You’re one of us. It’s very powerful.
Painter: But if Black men were not voting, all these controversies wouldn’t have been stirred up.
Ganz: It’s strange to me that there’s even a controversy about it. The 14th directly leads to the present day and debates we’re still having now. I mean, we literally just had a Supreme Court decision about birthright citizenship. If it had gone the other way, it would have been possible for the citizenship of Americans to be revoked by the executive branch.
Ken Burns: Frederick Douglass wrote about the 14th Amendment: “To tell me that I am an equal American citizen, and, in the same breath, tell me that my right to vote may be constitutionally taken from me by some other equal citizen of citizens, is to tell me that my citizenship is but an empty name.” That is waiting for the 15th Amendment.
But the promise made to Black men in the South, that they were now full citizens, quickly became illusory. Reconstruction incited a violent backlash. By the end of the 19th century, a murderous regime of white terrorism led to a severe rollback of rights and the imposition of Jim Crow. This brutal system ensured the survival of a rigid racial hierarchy and severely undermined the Reconstruction amendments in many parts of the country.
Oct. 19, 1868
A South Carolina Senator Murdered
B.F. Randolph, a negro preacher from the North and a member of the South Carolina State Senate, was murdered at Cokesburg, in Abbeville County, in this State, on Friday. … Three white men then rode up, dismounted and fired on Randolph, mortally wounding him in three places. Although it was broad daylight, the murderers were not recognized and made their escape.
Oct. 17, 1872
The Georgia Election
In counties more equally divided politically, fraud and intimidation were resorted to to hinder and prevent colored men from voting. In Bibb County, at the city of Macon, the Republicans, while peaceably casting their ballots, were fired on by the Democrats, four being murdered on the spot and twenty or more seriously wounded.
Nov. 11, 1898
Riot in South Carolina
With guns and rifles drawn on him, fifteen men lined up in the roadside. The negro was put out in the road and told to go toward the pile of four dead negroes. He started, there was a ring of rifles and Harrison pitched forward dead. … Eight negroes have been lynched within two weeks’ time in neighboring counties.
Resistance to interracial democracy was unremitting. For decades, Black Americans in the South suffered under violence and intimidation.
Rick Perlstein: Beginning in 1890, states like Mississippi introduced stratagems — literacy requirements and poll taxes, for instance — that denuded Black suffrage in the South to the vanishing point.
Gates: That’s one of the lessons to me. It’s not a positive lesson. On the one hand, America’s at its best with the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments. Then look at how quickly that is snatched away for Black people.
The reign of Jim Crow became so oppressive that Black Americans, especially in the South, effectively lost the right to vote.
But in the 1950s, the civil rights movement gained a new level of prominence. The goal was to reclaim the citizenship for Black Americans that had been promised after the Civil War.
June 13, 1963
N.A.A.C.P. LEADER SLAIN IN JACKSON; PROTESTS MOUNT
July 4, 1964
NEGROES IN SOUTH TEST RIGHTS ACT; RESISTANCE LIGHT
Negroes ate steak side by side with whites in a Danville, Va., restaurant yesterday for the first time. A Negro boy got a haircut in a previously all-white hotel barbershop in Kansas City, Mo. And Negroes went swimming in a previously segregated swimming pool in Savannah, Ga. They were among scores of Negroes who tested the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which was signed by President Johnson Thursday.
Aug. 7, 1965
Americus, Ga., Appoints 3 Negroes to Jobs as Voting Registration Clerks
One of those in the registration line was Mrs. Alva Lassiter, who said she did not know her age but believed it to be “over 87.” “The reason I say that is that I know somebody that is 87, and I’m older than he is.” “Anyhow,” she said, “I been here a long time and I ain’t never voted. Today the civil people came up and said, ‘It’s time,’ and I said, ‘Yessir, I’m ready.’”
In 1965, in response to the civil rights movement, Congress passed the Voting Rights Act, which outlawed the kinds of rank discrimination that kept Black voters away from the polls. It was meant to reinvigorate the meaning of the 15th Amendment.
And for many years it did: In the decades that followed, the increase in Black voting led to more Black elected officials, just as happened during Reconstruction.
Still, people have tussled over the law and its reach.
Starting with the Supreme Court’s Shelby decision in 2013, key elements of the 1965 Voting Rights Act have been eliminated or weakened in recent years.
April 30, 2026
JUSTICES REJECT DISTRICT MAP IN LOUISIANA; DECISION DEALS BLOW TO VOTING RIGHTS ACT
The legacy of the 14th Amendment has also come under attack, most notably in a 2025 executive order from President Trump rescinding birthright citizenship. Earlier this year, the Supreme Court rejected Trump’s order as unconstitutional.
Perlstein: One way of interpreting the three Reconstruction amendments is that they represent the greatest advance toward equal rights for human beings in the history of the planet. Another: They merely defined the terrain upon which those life-or-death arguments continue yet today.
Painter: Even after a civil rights movement cost lives and livelihoods, two generations ago, voting rights are still not secure.
Still, the country continues to express both its discontents and its hopes at the voting booth. This month, millions of Americans cast their ballots in the midterm elections. In the South, Black voters surged to the polls, motivated in part by anger over efforts to roll back the Voting Rights Act.
Nov. 5, 2026
The Supreme Court ruling in April that weakened the Voting Rights Act set off fears across the South that Black voters would be discouraged from turning out to vote and that gains in Black representation could be reversed.
And so community networks went to work. Elders at Black churches invoked their memories of the civil rights movement. Students at historically Black colleges and universities led marches and set up political events. And organizers who had spent years warning about the threat of disenfranchisement sought to convince a new generation that its vote mattered.
Since its founding, the United States has fought repeatedly over the true meaning of its democracy. Arguably no other country had ever shared so much power with its citizens — but our history is full of frequent racial backlashes and long periods in which many were denied electoral rights.
The 15th Amendment was a bold promise that democracy was for everyone, a promise the country has struggled to live up to. The struggle shows no signs of ending.
This article was written by New York Times Magazine editors, drawing on insights from our “Ten Days” jury and material from the Times archive.
Panelist comments have been edited and condensed.
Photograph and video credits Demonstrators waving flags: Pictorial Parade/Getty Images. 15th Amendment illustration: National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution. Video montage: Archive Films, via Getty Images (flag, voting); Bettmann, via Getty Images (1920s voters); Joe Raedle/Getty Images (citizenship ceremony); Gabe Dinsmoor/Getty Images (child). Frederick Douglass: Universal History Archive, via Getty Images. Funeral: Bettmann, via Getty Images. Angry mob: Gene Herrick/Associated Press. Selma march: Bruce Davidson/Magnum. Voting Rights Act: Lyndon B. Johnson Library. Al Northern: John Sotomayor/The New York Times.
