How can people possibly afford to live in one of the most expensive cities on the planet? It’s a question New Yorkers hear a lot, often delivered with a mix of awe, pity and confusion.
We surveyed hundreds of New Yorkers about how they spend, splurge and save. We found that many people — rich, poor or somewhere in between — live life as a series of small calculations that add up to one big question: What makes living in New York worth it?
Sonnie Brown spends long hours behind the counter at Sonbobs Coffee House, the charming cafe she owns on 28th Avenue in Astoria, Queens. Her regulars greet her by name, and she asks about their kids, their classes and the rest of their lives as she prepares their usual orders from memory.
But Ms. Brown considers the coffee shop to be her side hustle — at heart, she is an actor. She has sometimes racked up five TV and movie credits in a year, and she acts in commercials and on stages, too. Her recent work includes a part in the play “What You Are Now,” an appearance on the CBS crime drama “CIA” and a role as a judge on “Law & Order,” which she reprises about once a year.
Recently, though, acting has been slow. Last year, Ms. Brown made about $35,000 between theater and television work.
“I’ve had very good years, and when you have a good year, if you’re smart, you invest it or you save it,” she said. “And that’s what I do, because otherwise who knows what’s going to happen next year?”
“I’ve been very fortunate in the amount of work I’ve gotten,” she added. “I just haven’t always been able to support myself doing it.”
That’s where Sonbobs comes in. The cafe, where she sells homemade muffins, sandwiches, coffee and other goods, generated about $90,000 in revenue last year, though roughly $80,000 went toward her operating expenses. The remaining profit stayed in the shop’s bank account, separate from Ms. Brown’s personal finances.
“I just pay myself in food,” Ms. Brown said.
Keeping a Cafe Going
Since she opened Sonbobs in early 2018, Ms. Brown has seen her costs balloon. Her rent has risen to $2,500 from $1,700. Her electricity bill can run $500 a month, up from about $200 to $300.
This year, she said, she has to make around $7,000 per month to break even. Ingredients alone cost roughly $4,000 per month, including $500 or more for coffee from Porto Rico Importing Co., a Manhattan institution to which Ms. Brown has been a loyal customer since she lived on the Lower East Side three decades ago.
“I try to use the simplest, best ingredients that I can find with no preservatives and as few chemicals as possible,” she said.
Many of those ingredients come from a weekly trip to Costco. Much of the fresh produce she uses in her sandwiches and fruit-filled muffins comes from Elliniki Agora, a market a couple blocks from the cafe where she spends $40 to $60 per week, depending on what’s in season. Sandwich meats come from Key Food.
She spends extra for compostable coffee cups, plus $80 a month to have the shop’s compost picked up. Compostable lids, though, are prohibitively expensive.
“I will not sell anything that comes in a plastic bottle,” she said.
One Thing to Try
Ms. Brown, who was adopted from South Korea and grew up in Miami, moved to New York in the late 1980s shortly before she graduated from the University of Florida (as is customary for many actors, Ms. Brown declined to share her exact age). She took up a bartending job at a rock music club, but it wasn’t always smooth sailing.
“New York is a really hard place to live emotionally, dating, just trying to survive, paying exorbitant rent,” she said. “I was just like, ‘This sucks. I think I’m going to go to Hawaii.’”
But before leaving the city, she decided there was “something I can only do here and nowhere else in the world” that she wanted to try: acting lessons.
She was hooked. And as she hit each acting milestone she set for herself to advance in her budding career, it became clear that she would need to stay in New York for the long haul.
After stints in a few Manhattan neighborhoods, Ms. Brown settled in Astoria, where she has lived in the same two-bedroom, rent-stabilized apartment for 29 years. She pays about $1,600 a month in rent, which she splits with her husband and her son.
“We can’t afford to leave,” she said. “It’s been doable to make very little money with that rent.”
A Few Expenses
She has considered ways to bring in more money from the cafe, such as staying open later or serving more beer and wine. “But since it’s really the side hustle to acting,” she said, “I don’t make that commitment.”
Ms. Brown has gotten health insurance through the Screen Actors Guild on and off for the last two decades. But as the minimum earnings requirement has gone up, her coverage has become more tenuous. Last year, when she fell temporarily below the minimum, she had to pay for three months of COBRA, the supplemental program that allows individuals to keep their insurance by paying the entire premium.
She has relatively few other expenses. Her personal grocery bill is negligible because she eats at Sonbobs. She doesn’t take a regular paycheck from the cafe, but in recent weeks she received, for the first time, a small business grant from Wells Fargo for $25,000. The money will help her reach her goal of paying herself a lump sum of up to that amount this year.
Ms. Brown spends $50 to $70 a month on food for Acro, her 20-year-old cat who has recently taken up an interest in playing the piano in Ms. Brown’s home by tapping his paws on the keys.
And she is willing to splurge from time to time on theater tickets. “But the thing about having friends in theater is often you can get discounts or free tickets,” she said. “And if it’s free, I’m going.”
We are talking to New Yorkers about how they spend, splurge and save.
