He claimed to be a Florida doctor and pastor, but there is no record of him having a U.S. medical degree or leading a church.
He filed for bankruptcy, but his problems really began when he started promoting and broadcasting plans to become Haiti’s president, calling himself the country’s savior and boasting that he had the backing of the U.S. government.
Now, Christian Emmanuel Sanon is on trial in Miami, accused by federal prosecutors of conspiring to kidnap or kill the last elected president of Haiti, Jovenel Moïse, who was assassinated in his bedroom in July 2021.
In court, Mr. Sanon, dressed in a suit and tie, has the bearing of a statesman. But prosecutors say the 67-year-old Haitian American was nothing more than a con man.
The well-spoken Florida resident is accused of teaming up with a South Florida security firm and a hit squad of Colombian former military commandos, who stormed Mr. Moïse’s presidential residence at night and shot him at point-blank range.
The killing plunged Haiti into chaos that continues to grip the country with gangs controlling much of the capital, Port-au-Prince, preventing an election to replace Mr. Moïse. (His widow, Martine Moïse, has registered to run for president in an election that, for now, is scheduled next year.)
Mr. Sanon was arrested in Haiti a few days after the assassination and jailed. In 2023 he was transferred to U.S. custody, where he was denied bail and remains detained.
Mr. Sanon’s defense team has painted him as a naïve and trusting family man who became a pawn caught in a large multinational plot that he did not believe would end in assassination.
“He doesn’t have a nickel,” Humberto Dominguez, a defense lawyer, told the jury, suggesting that his client lacked the means or political savvy to be the mastermind portrayed by prosecutors.
Mr. Sanon testified in his own defense last week that he loves his country and only wanted to find a way to replace a president he believed was shredding Haiti’s democracy.
Mr. Sanon suggested he was trying to help the United States and even provided information about Islamic extremists suspected of establishing a toehold in Haiti, an issue the F.B.I. had been keenly interested in.
But in his opening statement to the jury, Sean McClaughlin, a prosecutor, described Mr. Sanon as “a repeat failed businessman masquerading as a mega pastor” who was heavily in debt and was driven by greed, arrogance and “a lust for power.”
Mr. Sanon, who was born and raised in Haiti, created a series of companies in Florida under his name, according to state corporate records, but without much success. In 2013, he filed for bankruptcy.
Mr. Sanon, who traveled frequently between Florida and Haiti, had no political experience. But he used his connections in the United States and his fluency in English, French and Creole to pose as an opposition leader who claimed falsely to have influential friends in the U.S. State Department, according to interviews and court records.
Jake Johnson, an expert on Haiti who has followed the Moïse assassination case closely, said Mr. Sanon made those same claims when he spoke with him in 2019.
He learned of Mr. Sanon because he was interested in identifying people trying to influence Haitian politics, said Mr. Johnston, a senior research associate at the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington.
During their conversation, Mr. Sanon described “actively making connections” inside the U.S. government who were backing his plan to take over Haiti, Mr. Johnston said. He never took him seriously, Mr. Johnston said, describing Mr. Sanon as “a serial liar with no real connections to power in Haiti.”
Douglas Lofland, a Florida businessman, also recalled Mr. Sanon boasting about his connections in the U.S. government in meetings they had in 2019 and 2020.
Introduced by a mutual acquaintance, Mr. Lofland was seeking help to address a dispute over a marble quarry project in Haiti.
“I truly believed he was in contact with people from the U.S. government, but I was beginning to suspect they may have been impostors,” he said. “He would never disclose the names.”
Parnell Duverger, a Haitian American who had taught economics, recalled meeting Mr. Sanon — also through mutual acquaintances — in the fall of 2020 at a pizzeria in South Florida to discuss a wildly ambitious multibillion dollar development plan for Haiti Mr. Sanon was floating to attract investors.
The plan envisioned a wide array of projects, including roads, hospitals, airports and seaports. But there was no indication where the financing would come from.
Over six months, Mr. Duverger said he participated in several video meetings that included several people who presented themselves as U.S. government advisers. But, according to evidence federal prosecutors presented in Mr. Sanon’s case, they had nothing to do with the U.S. government.
Mr. Duverger told The New York Times before his death earlier this year that he came to realize that Mr. Sanon’s plans were the result of an oversized ego. “He’s a very audacious, deceptive man,” Mr. Duverger said.
In 2020, Mr. Sanon also held numerous meetings in Haiti with local politicians and civil society leaders, pushing his candidacy, first as a future prime minister, and then as president, according to witness testimony at Mr. Sanon’s trial.
“He was always well dressed, with a tie,” Julio Loiseau, a community activist in Haiti who participated in several of the meetings, said in an interview. “They didn’t call him Pastor Sanon,’’ he added, referring to others at the meetings. “They called him Mr. President.”
Mr. Loiseau said local politicians would lobby Mr. Sanon for ministerial positions in his future government.
“He said he was sent by the State Department and was on a mission from God,” he added.
Mr. Sanon’s charisma coupled with the long history of U.S. involvement in Haiti, including a military occupation in the early 20th century, made it easier to convince people he had the backing of the United States, according to those who had met Mr. Sanon.
In 2021, Mr. Sanon enlisted a small Miami security firm, Counter Terrorist Unit Federal Academy, in his plans, according to court documents. The firm raised money to pay for weapons, gear and the Colombian mercenaries accused of killing Haiti’s president, prosecutors say. (Four defendants linked to the security firm were found guilty in May by a federal jury in Miami of conspiring in Mr. Moïse’s assassination.)
Mr. Sanon also recorded a video he shared widely that sought to rally people against Mr. Moïse, whom he had accused of human rights violations and plotting to remain in office beyond his term. The video described the president’s residence as a “rat’s nest.”
Mr. Sanon even reached out directly to the U.S. State Department in the weeks before the assassination, asking the newly-installed Biden administration for help in setting up a transitional government.
“Moïse has stolen the democracy Haitians died to create,” he wrote to a top official, according to a letter entered into evidence in Mr. Sanon’s trial.
The Biden administration never responded to the letter, but issued statements supporting Haiti’s official timeline for elections.
Mr. Sanon’s defense asserts that the government’s case has been built with the help of prosecution witnesses who have already pleaded guilty in the assassination plot and are seeking reduced sentences.
The defense also claimed Mr. Sanon had sought to provide information to the F.B.I. about Islamic extremists who were supposedly setting up training camps in Haiti.
F.B.I. agents did meet with Mr. Sanon in April 2021 in Miami, but quickly determined he had no useful information, according to testimony from the agents at Mr. Sanon’s trial.
Eventually, the Miami security firm realized that Mr. Sanon never enjoyed the popularity in Haiti he claimed and parted ways with him, witnesses said at the trial.
Still, prosecutors say, Mr. Sanon kept in touch with the assassination plotters right up to the night Mr. Moïse was fatally shot.
“He doesn’t pack up and go away,’’ Mr. McClaughlin told jurors. “He’s still 100 percent a part of the team.’’
When Mr. Sanon learned of Mr. Moïse’s death, the prosecutor said he expressed no shock or surprise, “only satisfaction.”
But in his testimony, Mr. Sanon said he never expressed support for the violent act.
