Good morning. It’s Tuesday. It’s been almost two weeks since a ransomware attack hit the Queens Public Library. We’ll find out how the 66 branches are coping. We’ll also look at the reaction to Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s move to disband a specialized police unit that has come in for criticism.
Dennis Walcott’s day began at 7:45 a.m. when he saw the look on William Goldband’s face.
Walcott is the president and executive of the Queens Public Library. Goldband is the library’s vice president for information technology. Walcott asked what was the matter.
The library had been hit by a ransomware attack. “The staff knew right away that there was a problem — they couldn’t log on,” Walcott said.
That was on Nov. 4. Last week, technical problems grounded airplanes across the country, and an outage involving Microsoft disrupted communications and work at schools, government agencies and offices around the world. On Monday, JPMorgan Chase, the nation’s largest bank, blamed a software bug for delays in processing transactions, which only added to the sense of apprehension about the computer-driven systems that sustain the rhythms of daily life.
Now it’s been almost two weeks since the attack on the Queens library system. The library’s website and its mobile app are still down. So are the public computers at all but seven of the library’s 66 locations.
But Wi-Fi is available at every library. You can borrow a book. Some of the checkout and return machines are back on, and in branches where they are not, librarians are writing down who borrowed which books. The librarians will put that information into the system when it becomes available.
You can also get a library card and check out a book immediately. Walcott said librarians simply squirreled away the application form that new cardholders fill out. “What we’re doing is storing the data until the time that we’re able to upload the data when we come back up,” he said, describing the retro approach as “going old school and doing what’s necessary before we had all the technology.”
Walcott would not estimate the percentage of operations that depend on its network and remain offline. “I really don’t want to put a number on it because our system is evolving as we speak,” he said on Monday. “Probably if you write this story on Friday, it will be different than what you’re getting right now.”
Walcott would not comment on what the hackers had demanded.
The city’s two other library systems said they had not seen evidence of a similar attack. A spokeswoman for the New York Public Library said its systems had continued to function normally; she would not discuss security protocols or infrastructure. A spokeswoman for the Brooklyn Public Library also declined to discuss safeguards in detail, although she called cybersecurity “an ongoing priority” and said the library regularly reviewed “lessons from incidents affecting peer institutions.”
The Queens libraries did not close after the attack. “That wasn’t even a question,” said Nick Buron, the chief librarian. Nor did any of them shorten their hours, Walcott said, and school groups have continued to visit libraries. And the 66 libraries have continued to print documents for people who emailed them in, because the library’s email system was not knocked out.
The Queens system is not the first to face a cyberattack. The Boston Public Library was hit in 2021. The Toronto library system and the British Library fell victim in 2023, and the Seattle system the following year.
Recovering from a ransomware attack can take time. It took the Seattle library system three months to bring its systems back online. The British Library said a year after that attack that it had finally restored access to the collections that had been available before.
The attackers on the Seattle library gained access to personal data belonging to nearly 27,000 people, according to the attorney general’s office in Washington State, which tracks information on data breaches. The Seattle Times reported that the hackers had collected information on library employees that was more detailed, including Social Security numbers and financial information.
The British Library said its attackers released some of the data they pirated to the dark web, including some personal information about library users. The breach in Toronto — where a follow-up report by the information and privacy commissioner of Ontario called the cyberattack “a wake-up call for stronger security” — involved personal information on just over 8,000 employees, past and present.
Weather
The sun will come out today as temperatures near 57. Tonight will be mostly clear, and temperatures will drop near 47.
ALTERNATE-SIDE PARKING
In effect until Nov. 26 (Thanksgiving Day).
QUOTE OF THE DAY
“I got 2.5 hours of sleep last night and then I had a 10-minute cat nap.” — Brad Vogel, who organized a 66-hour nonstop reading of Robert Caro’s 1,162-page book “The Power Broker.” Vogel read Pages 16 and 17 on the first night.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said that he was disbanding the Strategic Response Group, a specialized police unit that has been criticized for its handling of protests. My colleague Maria Cramer writes that he had a mission-accomplished tone when he announced the move on social media.
His message, when he appeared on television roughly an hour later, was more nuanced. He said that the changes would not make New York less safe. The police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, emphasized that point in an email to rank-and-file officers.
From now on, the mayor said, civilians “without weapons or arrest powers” from the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety will act as the first line of communication with protesters.
Police unions reacted angrily to Mamdani’s decision to take a different approach to protests, while criminal justice activists were pleased. “The thug unit has been disbanded,” said Donna Lieberman, the executive director of the New York City Liberties Union, one of the groups that represented protesters in a 2023 lawsuit that prompted a series of changes, including a slower police response to protesters.
METROPOLITAN diary
Cake check
Dear Diary:
My girlfriend and I stopped at a bakery on our way to the movies in Cobble Hill on a summer night. We wanted chocolate cake.
Cake in hand, we stepped into the theater’s lobby and handed the attendant our tickets. He eyed my wax paper bag suspiciously.
“What’s that?” he asked.
I told him.
He frowned.
“You can eat it on the sidewalk, or you can leave it here,” he said. “But you can’t bring it in.”
I said I’d leave it there.
He reached under a table and pulled out a large cardboard box. Inside were stacks of takeout containers filled with leftovers.
He tagged my slice of cake, perched it in the box and handed me a purple stub that warned, in a bold font, “We are not responsible for anything left overnight.”
After the credits rolled, we joined our place in line to claim our cake. The movie was bad, but at least the night ended with dessert.
— Brendan Holman
