Distrust among garment workers towards the minimum wage board, factory owners and labour leaders, coupled with the absence of active trade unions at factory level, is contributing to continued unrest in the apparel sector, according to labour leaders working on the ground.
They also point to local political rivalries, attempts to control the garment waste (jhut) trade and efforts by the banned Awami League to exploit the protests for political gain as factors behind the ongoing unrest.
Workers unaware of wage-setting process
Conversations with several workers involved in the ongoing protests in Savar and Ashulia today (17 November) suggest that many demonstrators have little understanding of the legal process for determining wages.
One worker said they were protesting to press their demands but had not been informed about the wage board’s progress or the status of its meetings.
At the workers’ request, The Business Standard is withholding the identities of those who spoke to TBS.
A female garment worker at a factory in Ashulia, where workers stopped working in the morning and management subsequently declared a holiday, said they had received no information about the wage board or its proceedings.
“Nobody tells us how much the wages will be, even though the board has been formed. Workers are saying the owners claim the situation is normal because we are not protesting, and that is why our wages are not being increased. That is why we are protesting,” she told TBS.
She said neither factory management nor anyone else had briefed workers on the wage revision process. She also could not say whether her factory had a trade union.
A worker at another factory in the industrial belt expressed similar frustration.
“The board has been formed, but it has not announced the minimum wage. What is the problem with announcing it?” he said.
When told that wage board meetings, proposals and negotiations take time, he said the protests would continue until the new wage was announced.
“As long as the wage is not announced, the protests will continue. Once it is announced, you will see everything return to normal,” he added.
Labour leaders point to distrust, political rivalries
Khairul Mamun Mintu, law and collective bargaining secretary of the Bangladesh Garments and Sweater Workers Trade Union Centre, told TBS that distrust was one of the main reasons behind the current situation.
“Workers already have doubts about the wage board. When one of its meetings was postponed, they began to think it was because the protests had stopped. They see it as a delaying tactic. That is why workers are now saying they will return home only after securing a decision,” he said.
He said the delay in forming the wage board had further fuelled uncertainty. Under the law, the board was supposed to be formed in July, but it was constituted only in November.
“There is confusion among workers about what is actually happening. They are not receiving the right information,” he added.
Kabir Hossain, joint general secretary of the National Garment Workers Federation, said most ordinary workers were unaware of the legal process for forming the wage board and determining wages.
“This lack of knowledge is one of the reasons the protests are continuing. When workers see us, the labour leaders, asking them to remain calm and explaining the wage revision process instead of standing shoulder to shoulder with them in the protests, they begin to suspect us as well. That creates another layer of distrust,” he told TBS.
He said local political rivalries, competition over control of the jhut trade and attempts by the banned Awami League to gain political advantage from the unrest could not be ruled out.
“Workers in this industry have accumulated grievances from past experiences. They may not have received leave or may have been treated poorly. Those grievances are now coming together,” he said.
Kabir also alleged that many labour leaders representing workers on the wage board had limited contact with workers at factory level.
Rafiqul Islam Sujon, president of the Garments and Industrial Workers Federation, said the absence of trade unions, or their inactivity where they exist, had left workers without effective representation during periods of unrest.
“Most factories do not have active trade unions. If unions are not active, how can leaders maintain any influence over workers?” he said.
“Many of the unions that exist have been set up by owners to serve their own interests and show buyers that they have union representation. That is the reality. Many factories do not have trade unions at all,” he told TBS.
He said active unions could organise regular training to help workers understand labour laws, their rights and the wage-setting process.
“But factory owners do not want trade unions to operate. If unions are active, workers’ legitimate rights have to be ensured, which may reduce owners’ profits. This is one of the reasons behind the lack of control over the workforce and the situation we are seeing now,” he added.
Labour leaders said addressing the unrest would require more active trade unions at factory level, regular training and awareness programmes, and better relations between owners and workers. They stressed that narrowing the gap between management and workers and ensuring regular communication could help prevent recurring unrest.
Industrial belt situation
Meanwhile, the overall situation in Savar and Ashulia remained calm by early afternoon, according to police.
Speaking to TBS around 1pm, Mohammad Mominul Islam Bhuiyan, superintendent of Ashulia Industrial Police-1, said workers had gathered on the streets in the Charabag area in the morning after some garment factories declared holidays, but later dispersed peacefully.
He said workers had blocked roads in front of Hemayetpur, Rajfulbaria and Bank Town in Savar. Members of the Border Guard Bangladesh, industrial police and Dhaka district police jointly used limited force to clear the roads.
At Padma Mor, some outsiders and workers from nearby factories also pushed against factory gates, but police removed them, he said.
“There was no clash. Police used sound grenades and tear gas to remove workers from the roads after they blocked traffic. The situation in Savar and Ashulia is now calm,” he added.
Mominul said more than 600 industrial police personnel had been deployed in Savar and Ashulia.
Eight factories remained closed under Section 13(1) of the Bangladesh Labour Act, while around 20 others had declared general holidays for various reasons, including workers’ refusal to work, he added.
