The Day That Gave Women Control
May 9, 1960: The F.D.A. approves the pill.
On the day the Food and Drug Administration approved the pill, birth control was still outlawed in several states, largely because religious groups were deeply concerned about separating sex from reproduction. The announcement came in the midst of a dramatic presidential race, and the F.D.A. feared a legal and moral backlash. Though the creation of synthetic sex hormones that suppressed ovulation was an undeniable scientific feat, news of the drug’s approval landed softly at first. In The Times the next day, the announcement was printed on Page 75 of a 76-page paper.
MAY 10, 1960
U.S. Approves Pill for Birth Control
“Approval was based on the question of safety,” Associate Commissioner John L. Harvey said today. “We had no choice as to the morality that might be involved.”
But the effects of the approval would be enormous. It was less about birth control itself, our panel argued, than it was about a woman’s ability to control her own life.
Nell Irvin Painter: F.D.A. approval meant that contraception could be regulated as safe and effective, unlike previous techniques that could be illegal, dangerous and ineffective.
Claudia Goldin: It replaced Russian roulette with certainty and allowed young people to divorce sex from marriage. It gave women the ability to have autonomy.
Painter: This invention revolutionized the meaning of women’s lives by uncoupling childbearing from their existence as human beings. I would argue that childbearing lies at the root of the equation of women as property of men. When women can make decisions about their lives as people, not as men’s property. This power profoundly reshaped women’s lives worldwide.
One way of telling the story of the pill would be to start on what used to be considered the women’s pages: the wedding announcements. In 1904, a Mayflower descendant, Miss Katharine Dexter, married the industrial heir Stanley F. McCormick.
Sept. 16, 1904
The bride’s dress was of white embroidered muslin, and she wore a magnificent set of pearls, the gift of the bridegroom.
The marriage was not a happy one. The bridegroom was soon institutionalized for schizophrenia. When he died in 1947, Katherine Dexter McCormick used the fortune he left her to fund her friend Margaret Sanger’s long-held dream of a birth-control pill.
Sanger, a social reformer with ties to the eugenics movement, had been promoting birth control for decades. At the time, the term “birth control” mostly referred to diaphragms and douches. Now, newly flush with the donation from McCormick and motivated in part by her desire to stem the population growth of India, Sanger and Planned Parenthood offered Dr. Gregory Pincus and his team a grant to work on oral contraception.
Much of the testing of the drug was done in Puerto Rico, where there were no anti-contraception laws and where there was a dense population of women, many of whom were poor and were not told that they were part of a clinical trial. Early on, British studies showed that at the suggested dose, the side effects were severe and in some cases even life-threatening. But the dosages were adjusted, and the pill caught on.
The thing that made the pill different from other birth control, as our panel pointed out, is that it was easy.
Siddhartha Mukherjee: Globally speaking, the IUD is much more important.
Goldin: But the IUD didn’t diffuse much in the U.S. in the 1960s. It’s painful. It’s expensive. We have lots and lots of contraceptive inventions, but it has to be something that people are going to use.
Married women, initially the most enthusiastic group, used the pill to further space apart their children and have fewer of them; unmarried women began to use it in large numbers in the 1970s. That meant that for the group of American women born in 1948, a full 85 percent of them would use the pill at some point during their lives.
In many ways, the pill became a dividing line between generations of women: Those who came of age just years before its widespread use were less likely to benefit from the enormous societal change that followed in its wake.
One woman wrote in the The Times in 1972 that she’d been born “too early for the pill” and now felt that she was neither entirely modern nor entirely traditional. Instead, she said, she was “lost.” But for women born after that line, suddenly they had a future with options. If biology could be tamed, women could at least imagine achieving equality for the first time in history.
By 1977, there were more American women than men enrolled in college. Single women stayed in school longer and progressed in their careers before having children. More women in white-collar jobs led to more women in white-collar jobs, and more women with power.
Painter: When childbearing no longer rules, women can become powerful politically, economically and socially, which threatens a society where only men are in charge.
march 21, 1965
German Women in Jobs Increase; Make Up More Than a Third of Nation’s Work Force
Feb. 12, 1973
Women Made Two‐Thirds of Gains of Jobs in 1960’s
May 14, 1978
Women Put Labor Force Over 100 Million Mark
Nov. 30, 1980
Women at the Top
Jane Evans is used to being the only woman in a man’s world. When she became president of Butterick and Vogue Patterns in 1974, she inherited an all-male team of vice presidents. “They made it known through the company that they weren’t especially pleased that a woman, a 30-year-old-woman — was now their boss,” Miss Evans recalled.
Soon, other secondary effects quickly became apparent.
Dating changed; marriage changed. Unmarried couples began to live together in the open. Sexual freedom had never been possible on this scale. The pill became a potent symbol for a new era of women’s liberation.
JULY 4, 1976
The Pursuit of Pleasure
In a sense, it is the only revolution we have today, and in considering its effects, which range from abortion on demand to epidemic venereal disease, it is easy to lose sight of its simple, private result, a result that is as remarkable as a 60-year‐old woman blurting out to a psychotherapist that she would like to try “fooling around”: The sexual revolution has made sexual pleasure more important to women.
Other freedoms followed. Equality and bodily autonomy started to seem tantalizingly close, and also painfully out of reach. That’s when the feminist movement went mass, as a headline and a photo caption in The Times demonstrated.
Feb. 9, 1969
Miss America Pageant Is Picketed by 100 Women
Girl revolutionaries picket Atlantic City’s Miss America contest last fall. To many of them, it epitomized everything they loathe: “a mindless, commercial boob-girlie” show.
April 23, 1970
Coeds Throw Pills at Rally
Participants in an Earth Day rally at Indiana University were pelted today with birth-control pills thrown by coeds dressed as witches. The girls danced in a circle and chanted, “Free our bodies, free our minds.”
April 12, 1970
Rockefeller, Signing Abortion Bill, Credits Women’s Groups
Abortion became the next lightning rod. Roe v. Wade became the law of the land — for half a century, anyway — built on the constitutional right to privacy that had been established in order to make birth control legal. The political ripple effects of abortion never stopped.
Rick Perlstein: Then there is backlash. The idea that anyone can have sex just brings down the curtain on a whole set of structuring norms about society that really freaks people out and makes someone like Ronald Reagan possible. The pill really is kind of like the killer app for reactionary politics.
Christopher Caldwell: That’s where reactionary politics was 50 years ago. Now, reactionary politics is preoccupied with the tragic fact that giving people control over birth in this way leaves countries with a population shortfall, which winds up creating either total implosion or immigrant societies.
John Ganz: Yeah, but you don’t need to have eight kids because four of them are going to die. Society needs fewer people to reproduce than it did. People on the right seem to think we’re getting into some crisis situation where we’re going to have a collapse.
Mukherjee: They’re not having enough babies in South Korea, and nor is Sweden, and nor is Japan. But there’s no evidence whatsoever that the fertility crisis has to do with how much child-productive sex people are having.
Goldin: The pill and other contraceptives have given women a choice in life. I can opt for having a career and a family, but to do that, I have to find a man who’s going to truly share with me in a world in which sharing may be very costly. That, I think, is the crux of the problem. I don’t call it a crisis.
Not every woman has wanted — or been able — to exercise every option that the pill made available. But they all live in a world transformed by it.
This article was written by New York Times Magazine editors, drawing on insights from our “Ten Days” jury and material from the Times archive.
Panelist comments have been edited and condensed.
Photograph and video credits Enovid-E 21 oral contraceptive: National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution. Video montage: Bloomberg, via Getty Images (graduation); Premiere Pictures, via Getty Images (wedding); Hearst Newsreel, via Getty Images (Gloria Steinem); BBC Archive, via Getty Images (demonstration); BBC Archive, via Getty Images (office workers); ITN, via Getty Images (Bhutto); FedNet/Getty Images (women in congress); Filioop Carlot/Getty Images (mother and child). Planned Parenthood: Don Hogan Charles/The New York Times. Work and education montage: Barton Silverman/The New York Times (class); Spencer Grant/Getty Images (graduation); Fred R. Conrad/The New York Times (computers); Barbara Alper/Getty Images (desk); H. Armstrong Roberts/Getty Images (machine); Chester Higgins Jr./The New York Times (conference). Sexual revolution montage: Mirrorpix, via Getty Images (sunglasses); Bettmann, via Getty Images (swinging bra); Jack Tinney/Getty Images (couple in bed); Frederick Kelly/The New York Historical/Getty Images (dancing); Bill Cunningham for The New York Times (kissing couple). Abortion rights demonstrators: John Sotomayor/The New York Times. Anti-abortion demonstrators: Teresa Zabala/The New York Times.
