To commemorate The New York Times’s 175th anniversary, The New York Times Magazine set for itself an impossible project: to select the 10 most consequential days since the paper began publishing. The Times, especially in its predigital period, was built on days: one paper per day (in several editions) offering, in the famous phrase, its “first draft of history.”
Every one of those days was important; but some were more so. History is hindsight. As time writes the second and third (though never final) drafts, certain days begin to emerge as hinge points, moments after which nothing would be the same, for good and for ill. Looking back, could we identify the days in the past 175 years that most dramatically shaped the world we live in now?
Last summer, we invited a jury of 13 esteemed historians and scholars to debate this question across a series of meetings. You can see a roster of their names below. They were generous, illuminating in their reflections and remarkably game, with several describing the process as the best sort of dorm-room debate. To force decisions, we pitted days against each other as if we were game-show hosts: If absolutely pressed, would you choose the invention of the plane or the automobile? (Of course, the panelists sometimes found the exercise exasperating — at one point the writer John Ganz threw up his hands and exclaimed, “This is totally arbitrary!”) To which we could only say, Yes, but. Assigning importance retrospectively is what historians do. Eventually, after much haggling, a final list emerged.
You’ll notice that each of the days illustrates a theme the panel deemed crucial to understanding our present. That was what the historians, being historians, noticed as well. It wasn’t intentional, but as the deliberations proceeded, they found they were organizing their own thinking by identifying significant contemporary strands and working backward. In part, that’s because we asked them to be “presentist,” to think about history through the lens of how it formed our current moment. (If we were doing this 10 years ago, or 10 years in the future, their choices might have been different, as what looks significant today can seem a little less significant tomorrow.)
We also asked them to take the whole world into account, though that world through an American perspective came to dominate their considerations — which made sense, because these 175 years were a period of America’s rising (and perhaps falling) global dominance. The selected days are also, of course, shaped by the composition of the jury itself, with its zones of expertise and biases. One admitted bias of our historians was that they, being historians, were reluctant to grant too much emphasis to recent events, not being certain how they would play out. They were more inclined to search for the roots of the major events of the recent past than to award those events themselves a place on the list. The election of Donald Trump, the screen in our pocket that took over our lives: These phenomena paled in their minds compared with the forces that made them seem, in retrospect, inevitable.
Once we had our list, we set out to tell the story of each day — what happened and how it reverberated through the years. Our tool was The Times’s own archive. One pleasure of The Times’s 175th birthday project, published throughout the paper over the past few months, has been the riches of its vault, some of which now looks prescient, some oblivious, but which is nearly always riveting in its contemporaneous accounting of what was known at the time.
Each day’s story is told immersively through headlines, excerpts from Times articles and selections from our historians’ debates. (A note on photographs: The paper didn’t publish them until 1910, and even then used them more sparingly than we do now, so we allowed ourselves to pull from beyond our own photographic record.) Sometimes, the event that came to figure so heavily in history didn’t make the next day’s front page, instead appearing deep in the paper alongside stories no one remembers, as well as advertisements for the most newfangled washing machines. Sometimes, it didn’t initially make the paper at all, and we could only watch the importance of an event gradually emerge in The Times’s reporting. We found ourselves constantly surprised while rooting around in the archive, learning, for instance, that The Times used to publish a Scientific Gossip column, or that a Times reporter was actually onboard the mission to bomb Nagasaki.
In addition, we’ve assembled a list of the Almosts: days that our historians made a strong case for — but didn’t make the final cut. The panelists’ discussion reveals both how history works and how difficult the assignment really was.
History is rarely made in a day. It is progressive, though never linear. One world war makes the next world war possible, perhaps even inevitable. Other events complicate the progression: a depression, say, which plays out over many pivotal days, creates the conditions for that war.
So dig in, and argue with the panel’s choices. History isn’t science. It’s judgment — and judgment is personal.
