The Day Evil Became a System
Jan. 20, 1942: The Nazis meet to plan a genocide.
On a winter day in 1942, in the wealthy Berlin suburb of Wannsee, a group of men gathered at a lakefront villa for a conference that lasted about 90 minutes. They sat in a dining room with large windows overlooking the water. Afterward, cognac was served. The men — high-ranking Nazi and state government officials — had assembled to settle on a plan for the systematic extermination of the Jews.
The Nazis had been working for a decade to transform the broad antisemitism that shaped Hitler’s rise into something more organized. Assisted by punch cards and tabulators, they identified millions of European Jews and divided them into a growing network of ghettos and work camps. They had already killed about a million Jews by firing squad and starvation.
But the Nazis meant to completely rid Europe of its Jewish population, and as World War II progressed, that meant scaling up and systematizing their efforts across the continent. In their discussion at what later became known as the Wannsee Conference, the methods of killing were clear, but the record cloaked this “final solution of the Jewish problem” in bureaucratic code words and euphemisms. The Jews, according to carefully edited notes from the meeting, would be “utilized for work in the East,” where “a large portion will undoubtedly drop out through natural reduction.” Those who survived would be “given suitable treatment because they unquestionably represent the most resistant part and therefore constitute a natural selection that, if released, become the germ cell of renewed Jewish revival.”
The Wannsee Conference, our panel argued, represented something new: the creation of a technocratic, industrial form of mass killing that would reverberate far beyond the Holocaust.
Christopher Caldwell: The Wannsee Conference is where the Nazis met to lay out how they would go about removing the Jews from the earth.
Rick Perlstein: The Final Solution was mapped out there: We all agree that the presence of Jews in Germany is a problem; here’s the final solution to that problem.
Marie Arana: You’ve got the devastation of a community in which two-thirds of its population was wiped out. The human cost was huge. The genocide ultimately affected everybody around the globe.
Caldwell: Of course, there’s a long history of real, radical enmities of one people against another.
Perlstein: There’s a sense among some intellectuals that there have been a lot of Holocausts: you know, Ukraine under Stalin, Armenia, tens of millions of Indians died.
Henry Louis Gates Jr.: But it was the systematic, planned nature of the Holocaust that makes it so unusual. The Wannsee Conference was: Here’s the blueprint for murder.
The conference was held in secret, and news of its proceedings did not come out for several years. But by 1942, ample evidence already existed that the Nazis were making a concerted effort to eliminate the Jewish people. By and large, The New York Times’s coverage failed to capture the reality of what was happening, something that later generations of Times leadership would openly acknowledge.
Some of the most disturbing instances of the Nazi campaign were reported, but much of that coverage was buried deep in the paper, such as this article, published less than two months after the Wannsee Conference:
March 1, 1942, page 28
Extinction Feared by Jews in Poland
As the massacre plotted out at Wannsee became a reality, the barbarity of the Nazi death camps was becoming more widely understood. In 1944, The Times published a reporter’s front-page dispatch from inside a liberated concentration camp:
Aug. 30, 1944
Nazi Mass Killing Laid Bare in Camp
I have just seen the most terrible place on the face of the earth. … I have been all through the camp, inspecting its hermetically sealed gas chambers, in which the victims were asphyxiated, and five furnaces in which the bodies were cremated, and I have talked with German officers attached to the camp, who admitted quite frankly that it was a highly systemized place for annihilation.
The scale of the Nazi extermination camps shocked the world. This was a type of methodical, industrialized mass murder that had never been seen before. And it led to a new moral and legal framework. The Polish-Jewish lawyer Raphael Lemkin, who himself lost dozens of relatives in the Holocaust, first used the word “genocide” in his 1944 book “Axis Rule in Occupied Europe” to describe the coordinated annihilation of an entire ethnic group.
Lemkin persuaded the prosecution at the Nuremberg trials — where leaders of Nazi Germany were called to account for their crimes — to use the word in their official indictment. What Winston Churchill had once called a “crime without a name” had entered the language of the law.
Oct. 2o, 1946
Genocide Is the New Name for the Crime Fastened on the Nazi Leaders
This crime was mapped out at the Wannsee Conference. In 1961, the trial of Adolf Eichmann revealed the particular depravity of the meeting. Eichmann spoke of participants who “outdid and outbid each other, as regards the demand for a Final Solution to the Jewish question.” And he made clear that the decisions made that day set the course for what followed.
June 27, 1961
Eichmann Testifies He Felt Like Pilate
“When the elite — the veritable popes of the regime — cast the die, there was nothing for me to do but conform,” he said. “I had a feeling like Pilate — free of any guilt. I had to toe the line, of course, willy-nilly, but it was not with me that the guilt lay.”
The lead prosecutor called him “a new kind of killer, the kind that exercises his bloody craft behind a desk.” Eichmann was executed by hanging the following year.
Nell Irvin Painter: It might be said that Eichmann was the Wannsee Conference’s greatest publicist. The pivotal evidence against him was his presence in the Wannsee villa. And because, in 1942, the conference was secret, it didn’t become the symbol, the widely accepted embodiment of genocide, until Eichmann’s testimony.
Gates: Before Wannsee, no one else had ever sat down with a blueprint quite like this to say: How can we kill these people? Yes, in America, there had been the Indian Removal Act and the Trail of Tears. But it wasn’t the same as these lunatics, the Nazis, citing the forces and legitimacy of science, and then drawing on our own Jim Crow laws in the South to figure out how to kill six million Jewish people in four years.
In 1948, the U.N. adopted its first human rights treaty, the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.
In the decades since, many other governments around the world have been accused of emulating the racialized, systematic violence of the Holocaust.
Feb. 6, 1981
U.N. Panel Says Cambodia’s Ills Spring From Genocide by Pol Pot
A diplomat … described events in Cambodia as “without precedent in our century, except for the horror of Nazism.”
sept. 14, 1993
World Court Presses Belgrade on Genocide Issue
The World Court today demanded “immediate and effective implementation” of its past orders that the Belgrade Government refrain from committing or sponsoring acts of genocide in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Feb. 13, 1997
U.N. Report Comes Down Hard on Rwandan Genocide Tribunal
The United Nations issued a scathing report today on the International Criminal Tribunal it set up to investigate the 1994 genocide of over half a million Tutsi and Hutu in Rwanda and judge those held responsible.
July 19, 2018
Myanmar’s Military Planned Rohingya Genocide, Rights Group Says
The 162-page report says that the exodus of around 700,000 Rohingya Muslims to Bangladesh last year … was the culmination of months of meticulous planning by the security forces.
The legacy of Wannsee went far beyond the introduction of a new kind of war crime and a framework for how to prosecute it. The Holocaust also motivated sweeping changes in the global order. For decades, Zionist intellectuals and political activists had sought a permanent home for the Jewish people. In the aftermath of the war, they and others argued that the creation of Israel was an existential imperative: Jewish refugees trying to escape the Nazis had been barred from ports across the globe, and many still remained in European displaced-persons camps.
But the establishment of Israel in what was then known as the Palestine Mandate — uprooting more than 700,000 Palestinians amid a U.N. partition and a violent war — created a bitter, enduring conflict.
Caldwell: Being stateless had been one of the hallmarks of the Jewish nation. The establishment of an actual nation-state for a people that had been without one for like 2,000 years, that’s a hugely significant thing.
Arana: The creation of Israel set in motion mass migration and fundamentally reshaped geopolitics.
Perlstein: Yes, another thing here is: No Holocaust, probably no state of Israel. And no Israel, no Middle East conflict.
That conflict intensified following the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, and Israel’s military response in Gaza. Human rights groups and legal scholars have argued that Israel’s actions in the Gaza war meet the definition of genocide.
Dec. 5, 2024
Amnesty International Accuses Israel of Genocide in Gaza
Amnesty International on Thursday became the first major international human rights organization to accuse Israel of carrying out genocide in Gaza, drawing a rebuke from Israeli officials who denied the claim.
Today, the word “genocide” is inescapable in discussion, coverage and prosecution of human rights atrocities. But it has also become a moral and political flashpoint.
Aug. 20, 2024
The Bitter Fight Over the Meaning of ‘Genocide’
Gates: Lots of people have since used the words “genocide” and “Holocaust” to refer to their own oppression in the middle of wars, or after wars. So I think it led to a kind of comparative suffering: I suffered a Holocaust. Mine was greater than yours. Postwar identity politics led to a war of meaning, a war for applicability. You can see it now in arguments about Gaza. Was it a Holocaust? Was it genocide? What is it?
Beverly Gage: Ultimately, in the U.S. as elsewhere, the Holocaust became the great cautionary example about the power of racism, unrestrained militarism, dictatorship, even modern bureaucracy, to become justifications and tools for inhumanity and mass murder.
Over the decades, The Times has lamented the muted way it covered the Holocaust as it was happening. In 2001, on the occasion of the paper’s 150th anniversary, the former executive editor Max Frankel wrote unsparingly about The Times’s journalistic shortcomings during this period.
Nov. 14, 2001
Turning Away From the Holocaust
The staggering, staining failure of The New York Times to depict Hitler’s methodical extermination of the Jews of Europe as a horror beyond all other horrors in World War II — a Nazi war within the war crying out for illumination.
What began at the Wannsee Conference will loom over us always, not because it showed that people were capable of mass murder, which the world already knew, but because it showed what could happen when that will to murder was attached, by the most ambitious administrators, to the most advanced methods.
For years, the Wannsee villa was run as a schullandheim, a kind of school retreat where children from the working-class district of Neukölln could take in the fresh air and run on the green lawns. Then, in 1992, half a century after the conference, the villa reopened as a memorial and library.
In a dispatch from that ceremony — headlined “Germany Marks Place Where Horror Began” — The Times quoted a speech by an Auschwitz survivor named Heinz Galinski, whose family had been killed by the Nazis. Before the gathered crowd, Galinski said:
Jan. 20, 1992
“In this house, on Jan. 20, 1942, a barrier of civilization was broken and the abyss of barbarism was opened.”
This article was written by New York Times Magazine editors, drawing on insights from our “Ten Days” jury and material from the Times archive.
Panelist comments have been edited and condensed.
Photograph and video credits Nazi soldiers marching during a Nuremberg rally: Discovery Access, via Getty Images. Wannsee villa: Bettmann/Getty Images. Reinhard Heydrich: DPA/Picture Alliance, via Reuters Connect. Majdanek concentration camp: Sovfoto/Universal Images Group, via Alamy. Majdanek ovens: Abraham Pisarek/Deutsche Fotothek, via Getty Images. Adolph Eichmann: John Milli/GPO, via Getty Images. U.N. Security Council: Milton Grant/U.N. Photo. Rohingya refugees: Adam Dean for The New York Times. Gaza Strip: Bashar Taleb/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images.
