The art market’s grand finale beginning Monday comes with a $2.8 billion forecast — and plenty of drama.
A late-breaking claim by heirs of the Jewish former owner of a van Gogh landscape has challenged a Sotheby’s auction Wednesday of a painting of blossoming chestnut trees, which was expected to sell for about $180 million.
The heirs, in an email to the auction house from their lawyer that was shared with The New York Times, said that the canvas was originally sold under Nazi-era duress in 1936, and that they were “prepared to work toward a fair and just solution.”
The high-stakes clash underscores how heavily the three major auction houses are betting on tradition at the New York fall marquee sales of contemporary and modern art. Counting the van Gogh, they are estimating they will sell about $600 million more than last November, when one collector brought a shimmering Klimt portrait home for over $236 million, making it the second-most expensive painting ever auctioned.
Experts said the new estimates reflected a surge in high-value works and signs of confidence in the buying appetites of the ultrawealthy, despite the potential for rising interest rates and recent stock market wobbles.
“There’s been a lot of wealth created since Covid, and there’s still a tremendous appetite this fall for top-quality material that’s fresh to market,” said Liz Sterling, a partner at the New York- and Palm Beach-based advisory firm Sterling Teel Capital.
Christie’s, Sotheby’s and Phillips have mostly relied on death and debt to fill their marquee auctions, though discretionary selling is on the rise. The offerings include a $120 million portrait by Cézanne from an estate built on Argentine sugar wealth and a $60 million portrait by Picasso from the private collection of Jeff Koons, one of the most famous living artists.
The offerings reinforce the growing divide between the market’s top end and everything underneath. The three houses are now offering 47 lots expected to sell for at least $10 million, up from 29 such lots in last November’s equivalent sales. You can expect more traditional works, like an Edward Hopper sailboat painting and an Alberto Giacometti bronze, each priced around $30 million. Still, the very highest price echelon remains thinner than it was at the market’s recent peak. With the van Gogh, there are only two lots estimated above $100 million, compared with five works that sold above that threshold during the 2022 Christie’s estate sale of the Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen.
“Auctioneers or specialists in the past would have said, ‘It’s our job to lead the market, to not only respond to trends but to direct them,’” said the New York-based adviser Alex Glauber. “This season feels much more reactive than proactive in that regard.”
What are they reacting to? One answer is the sustained retreat from speculation on young artists, who are scarce in the week’s evening auctions. Another is the attraction to brand-name luxury objects, such as Patek Philippe watches, by global investors whose fortunes have grown dramatically.
“We’re seeing this flight to blue-chip historical artwork, and some of that has to do with people rotating capital out of investments that have perhaps been wealth-generative but also volatile and uncertain,” said Charles Stewart, Sotheby’s chief executive, referring broadly to turbulence in politics and the financial markets.
As the art market prepares for its biggest sales week of the year, here are five bellwethers to watch.
A Sugar Heiress’s Trove
Sotheby’s Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection Evening Auction, about $450 million, Wednesday
The Impressionist and modern collection of the Argentine sugar heiress Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier and Carlos Pedro Blaquier is the crown jewel of this month’s auctions, but closer scrutiny last week revealed a discrepancy potentially worth about $180 million.
The vibrant van Gogh landscape “Châtaigniers en fleurs (Blossoming Chestnut Trees),” from 1890, could be withdrawn from the auction — or, if the claim is settled before Wednesday, go on to sell for more. Among 12 lots expected to make about $450 million, the trove also contains Paul Cézanne’s “Arlequin” (1888-90), estimated in the region of $120 million.
The disputed van Gogh landscape changed hands multiple times between 1936 and its acquisition by the Blaquier-Arrieta family in 1975. It now hangs in the balance of negotiations between Sotheby’s, the Blaquier-Arrieta estate and the heirs’ lawyers. “While our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress, we recognize the importance of engaging thoughtfully and constructively with the family and are committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution,” the auction house said.
Backed by a financial guarantee from Sotheby’s to the consignor, the van Gogh would likely eclipse the Dutch artist’s current auction record of $117.2 million for a landscape sold at Christie’s in 2022, at the Paul Allen sale (about $135 million in today’s dollars).
Painted within four days of his arrival in pastoral Auvers following a year spent in a psychiatric asylum, the verdant chestnut trees against a gathering storm can be read as symbols of the artist’s emotional struggle. Now the composition could equally symbolize the clash over its ownership.
Jeff Koons’s Personal Art Collection
Heroes & Lovers: Property of a Distinguished Collector, $150 million, Christie’s 20th Century Evening Auction, Tuesday
In the late 2000s, as his own market ascended on the sale of balloon-animal sculptures, the artist Jeff Koons went on a buying spree. He scooped up work by artists who inspired him, like Picasso, Manet and the Dutch Golden Age painter Cornelis van Haarlem. Seven of those works are expected to sell for a total of more than $100 million as part of the 20th-century evening sale Tuesday at Christie’s, with Picasso’s passionate canvas “Le Baiser” estimated at $40 million to $60 million.
Although his name doesn’t appear in official materials, Koons is undoubtedly the consignor. “The fact that he owned these only adds to the mystique around the works,” said Jacob King, an art adviser, noting that strong provenance can lead to higher prices even when an artist like Koons doesn’t necessarily want his name associated with a sale.
A person close to the Christie’s deal said that Koons’s motivation for selling the collection was to invest back into his art practice.
Joseph Yaeger
“My determinate” (2021), $80,000-$120,000, Phillips Modern and Contemporary Art Evening Auction, Tuesday
Demand for younger artists has fallen sharply since the speculative frenzy peaked five years ago. But the market still anoints a few stars each season.
The name of the moment is Joseph Yaeger, a 40-year-old Montana-based painter of closely cropped and altered film stills. The artist’s use of watercolor on gesso gives his surfaces a pockmarked, crackled quality. Collectors vied for paintings from Yaeger’s show this fall at Gladstone in New York, where advisers said prices ranged from $35,000 to around $200,000.
Experts anticipate his prices at auctions this week — at Phillips on Tuesday and Christie’s on Thursday could go significantly higher. Last month, a dramatically lit painting of a woman’s face by Yaeger sold in London for nearly $855,000 — a 79 percent rise over his previous auction record, set just six months earlier.
“There’s pent-up demand,” the art adviser Benjamin Godsill said. “If you need to have one of these right now, access to capital is easier than access to paintings.”
Yayoi Kusama
“Starry Pumpkin,” 2021, $1.8 million to $2.8 million, Christie’s 21st Century Evening Auction, Thursday
When the Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama died this year at 97, critics debated whether her commercial success had overshadowed her artistic vision. A market juggernaut, she was one of the few artists (and the only woman) to cross $1 billion in total auction sales, according to the market database ARTDAI.
Can the strength of her market survive doubts about her involvement in late-career works? Kusama’s last public appearance was in 2017, fueling speculation that her studio assistants directed the production of large-scale works, like her pumpkin sculptures. Authorship doubts would typically decrease the valuation of an artwork, but this week’s sales will show whether Kusama is an exception to the rule.
“There hasn’t been a test of Kusama for the late works since she died,” the adviser Wendy Cromwell said.
Gustav Klimt
“Litzlbergkeller” (1915-16), $60 million to $80 million, Christie’s 20th Century Evening Auction, Tuesday
Klimt was “one of the least prolific of the great modern painters,” said Max Carter, a Christie’s executive.
The artist completed only about 50 landscapes, many of which are owned by museums unlikely to sell. But just a year after three of Klimt’s paintings sold for almost $400 million combined at Sotheby’s, an anonymous seller is hoping to capitalize on the artist’s popularity with “Litzlbergkeller,” an intimate view of Klimt’s beloved lakeside retreat.
David Schrader, a founder of the dealership Pace Di Donna Schrader Galleries, said the demand for premier Klimt works is “certainly deeper and broader than we would have thought two years ago,” spanning the Americas, Europe and Asia. Even if no other bidders emerge, the financial guarantee already made by a third party ensures “Litzlbergkeller” will be among the week’s top sellers.
