Good morning. Today, I am handing it over to my colleagues.
Infighting among Democrats is a historical truism, like death or taxes. And even with their nationwide midterm victories this month, there are still debates to settle. Democrats disagree with one another about tariffs, Israel, the role of fossil fuels, how much to overhaul health insurance and how much to tax the rich. (They broadly agree on data centers and the Iran war: Nobody wants those.)
Democrats looked a lot different this year than they did in recent cycles. Some torched liberal orthodoxy and ran from the right on certain issues. Others embraced socialist ideas like national health care. Most of them won. Democrats captured control of Congress and most governorships.
If defeat is an orphan, victory has many parents. Now both the moderates and the progressives agree the party’s new big-tent approach enabled its victory, even as they argue that their sect provided the juice. Who is right, and how divided is the party, really? After all, both factions ran — and won — mainly on affordability, a thing they agree about.
Let’s look at the arguments.
The moderates
Moderate Democrats flipped seats in Kansas, Texas, Mississippi, South Carolina — deep-red places where the party does not typically win statewide races.
In their recruiting, party leaders prioritized candidates who could pass muster with local voters over those who lined up with the liberal orthodoxy on every (or any) issue. “None of the eight people who flipped Senate seats in Trump states ran on Bernie Sanders’s signature policies, and almost all of them ran to the right of the establishment,” Matthew Yglesias, a liberal journalist, told us, predicting a victory in Alaska.
Many of the newbies flayed the Biden administration’s immigration policy; Josh Turek of Iowa, for instance, backed a state law that made undocumented immigration a crime. James Talarico of Texas wants an “all-of-the-above” strategy for energy that still draws on fossil fuels. Annie Andrews of South Carolina said, “I don’t support biological men playing women’s sports, and I don’t support — and haven’t ever performed — gender surgery for minors.” Scott Colom of Mississippi ran on his 94 percent conviction rate as a tough-on-crime district attorney. These are not views that would have been welcomed by party leaders in 2020 or even 2024.
The result was a series of blowouts: Democrats’ margin of victory in Senate races was about 20 points in North Carolina, 18 in Georgia, five in Kansas, five in Iowa. The Blue Dog Coalition in Congress, the party’s self-described home for pragmatic bipartisanship, doubled its size. Democratic strategists wonder whether they’ve changed the electoral map for the 2028 presidential election, putting red states in play.
At the same time, these moderates shared an economic populism with the progressives. They ran on taxing the rich, ending foreign wars, stopping data centers and overhauling the health insurance system. It’s also hard to separate the impact of ideology from other personality-driven attributes — likability, candidate quality, vibes.
The progressives
Establishment Democrats groaned over the summer when their more progressive colleagues won primaries in places like Michigan, Maine and Florida. These left-wingers, campaigning on ideas like Medicare for All and halting aid to Israel, overcame enormous cash disadvantages with old-fashioned organizing and a clear message. Some espoused democratic socialist principles.
Democratic leaders fretted that these candidates would cost the party winnable races. Sure, they could persuade hard-core Democrats in a primary election. But could they appeal to swing voters in purple states like Michigan and Maine?
The midterm elections seemed to deliver a verdict: Yes, they could. The party will now have the most anti-Israel U.S. senator since the formation of the Jewish state 78 years ago in Abdul El-Sayed, who won the Michigan Senate race by seven points. Troy Jackson won in Maine by six points. Democratic socialists snagged dozens of elected offices, including eight House seats and the mayoralty in Los Angeles. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the democratic socialist who is mulling a run for president, said that “if Abdul can win in Michigan, anybody can win anywhere.”
Many centrists, however, are unmoved. Left-wing candidates this year underperformed their moderate peers and won their races by smaller margins, according to our colleague Nate Cohn, The Times’s chief political analyst. In Florida, for instance, the democratic socialist Angie Nixon lost her Senate race.
A new taxonomy
For voters, it’s not clear these fine-grained policy distinctions matter, nor that they describe the blocs accurately. Democrats who bickered in the primary were largely unified in the election when it came to the cost of living, the war, the role of billionaires, and the nepotism and self-dealing of the Trump administration.
Yet that doesn’t mean El-Sayed and Chuck Schumer, the likely majority leader from New York, want the same thing for the party. (Schumer is already facing a challenge from the left.) So how best to understand the new dynamic? It’s about “insurgent versus establishment, outsider versus insider, populist versus elitist, pugilist versus accommodationist,” David C. Barker, a political scientist at Brookings, wrote during the primaries.
That sentiment was already evident in May, when 58 percent of potential Democratic supporters told Times/Siena pollsters that their party doesn’t fight President Trump hard enough. Third Way, a centrist group, found that nearly nine in 10 Democrats would back a candidate they disagreed with on some issues if he or she battled for working people. They were, we now know, telling the truth.
MORNING READS
-
Relentless Russian attacks on the power grid in Ukraine are threatening to make some cities unlivable.
-
A leaderless student movement in Serbia defeated the country’s strongman in a recent election. But can it now govern?
-
Mark Carney, the prime minister of Canada, is visiting Asia as a political star. He hopes to build trade alliances and reduce his country’s economic dependence on the United States.
-
Miguel Ángel Félix Gallardo, a notorious drug lord in Mexico who helped build the foundations of the modern drug trade, has died at 80.
Other Big Stories
OPINIONS
The 2026 election wasn’t just about affordability, according to the writer Astra Taylor: Antifascism was a key theme too.
The manosphere’s misogyny is tearing conservative colleges apart, a family policy researcher writes.
TODAY’S NUMBER
5,000
— At least that many people have died since May in a fast-spreading Ebola outbreak in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Experts fear it is growing so quickly that it may surpass the West Africa epidemic of 2014 to 2016, the largest on record, in which more than 11,000 died. Declan Walsh and Daniel Berehulak have traveled for weeks through remote towns in eastern Congo to track the disease against a backdrop of exhaustion and Islamic State violence. Read their account.
SPORTS
Basketball: The Toronto Tempo won the W.N.B.A. draft lottery, earning the No. 1 pick in 2027. But will the U.S.C. star JuJu Watkins, the likely top choice, actually enter the draft?
National Women’s Soccer League: The Kansas City Current will play the Washington Spirit in the title game after defeating Gotham FC, the reigning champions, in the semifinals. Read a recap.
Hockey: The United States and Canada meet today in the gold medal game at the women’s hockey World Championship. Here’s what to know about the latest installment of the rivalry.
RECIPE OF THE DAY
I’m continuing Thanksgiving tryouts this week, tonight with this smart and easy apple-maple baked Brie situation that makes the most of a supermarket Camembert. Sarah DiGregorio, who developed the recipe, sprinkles pumpkin seeds over the top, but I’ll swap in slivered smoked almonds because I’m reckless, and serve the result with crackers and sliced apples. It’s neither an appetizer nor a side dish, but it still could find a place on the holiday table. Tonight, it’s dinner.
The actress Julia Garner is known for disappearing into difficult roles: You may have seen her in “The Americans,” “Ozark” or “Weapons.” Her latest transformation is in “The Altruists,” Netflix’s limited series about the rise and fall of the crypto founder Sam Bankman-Fried. Garner plays Caroline Ellison, Bankman-Fried’s off-again-on-again romantic partner. “I like to become different people,” Garner told The Times. “I am really just trying to completely disappear.” Get to know her.
More on culture
-
A Dutch theater collective wanted to adapt Trump’s 1987 advice book, “Trump: The Art of the Deal,” for the stage. They tried to buy the rights, but the inquiries went unanswered. So they went ahead without them and now “Die Kunst des Deals” is in repertoire in Western Germany. It’s an absurdist musical with roller skaters, dancing gold bars and a 10-foot banana — and it has become a critical and audience hit. Take a look.
-
We got Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller to sit down and talk to us about their new film, “Paper Tiger.” They spoke about getting into character, their relationships with one another in real life, and what it was like to film with ’80s technology. Read the conversation.
-
Jewish heirs are challenging Sotheby’s scheduled auction of a van Gogh painting, claiming it was sold under Nazi-era duress.
THE MORNING RECOMMENDS
Read “Stations,” Louise Kennedy’s second novel. It’s about longing and love. “A lot of American fiction of late seems muffled and solitary, as if it has expensive noise-canceling headphones clapped over its covers,” writes Alexandra Jacobs, one of our critics. “Stations,” though, “arrives like a boombox carried defiantly on someone’s shoulder through the subway. It’s built on dialogue, crackling with insult.”
Own your awkwardness. Laughing at yourself when you commit a faux pas shows that you’re comfortable with yourself and your imperfections. That makes you relatable and authentic.
Acquire some good wine glasses for your Thanksgiving table. The vinaceous barbacks at Wirecutter found the best goblets at myriad price points.
Take our news quiz.
