Daniel Benjamin teaches English and advises the school newspaper, The Blue and White, at Abington Friends School in Jenkintown, Pa.
Do you have an idea? Tell us here.
Like most English teachers, I’ve been reflecting on my classroom practices since the arrival of ChatGPT. This has led me to prioritize three types of assignments: those with real-world stakes, those I can break into smaller pieces and those that students are likely to care about intrinsically rather than just for a grade.
No assignment is A.I. proof, but I find that The New York Times Learning Network’s Student Opinion feature checks all these boxes.
Student Opinion has become a staple of my classroom because of the opportunities it provides students to write for authentic audiences, have their work published and practice engaging in civil discourse. Beyond these loftier goals, the daily prompts and linked articles offer opportunities for targeted skill practice that are applicable to a range of levels.
Here are some ideas if you would like to try it, too.
Learn how the feature works
For those who haven’t used this feature, here’s a brief summary:
-
Every day, The Learning Network posts “a new question that invites students to read an article from The New York Times and respond with their own ideas and opinions.”
-
Each question links to a recent Times article, which is always free if students access it from The Learning Network.
-
The prompts range widely. One week this spring, for example, students weighed in on personal experiences (summer jobs and symbols of their hometowns), arts preferences (the greatest living songwriter), issues related to education (writing by hand) and broader ethical topics (recording people without their knowledge). This is a representative sample: If you choose any week in the school year, you’ll find a similar breadth of topics.
-
Every Thursday, Times editors look over the latest prompts and choose one with interesting student engagement. They then spotlight their favorite comments on the issue via a post in their Current Events Conversation column. Later, in a weekly newsletter, the editors quote a handful of these students.
Offer your students choice
While I sometimes have the entire class respond to the same article, more typically I invite them to respond to any one of the five most recent Student Opinion prompts. That way, students can follow their own interests, and I get to learn what they are thinking about. When I’m grading that writing later, it’s a pleasure to have variety rather than 40 paragraphs answering the same question.
These comments give me windows into students’ experiences that I might not otherwise have. I’ve learned that some of them find lifeguarding boring, wish they still did more writing by hand, think that María Zardoya of the Marías is the greatest songwriter of all time and feel uncomfortable being near any student wearing smart glasses.
By giving students choices, I increase the chances that they will find topics in which they are genuinely interested. In my experience, that makes them less likely to resort to the shortcut of artificial intelligence.
Scaffold to amplify the skills you are teaching
In each Student Opinion post, The Learning Network poses several questions beyond the one in the main headline. For example, in “How Young Is Too Young to Get a Smartphone?,” the post asks students about their own experiences, their reactions to quotes and data from experts on the subject, and experiments in which communities have tried to limit early smartphone adoption. The questions are varied and invite personal anecdotes, arguments and connections with what students know and have experienced.
In my Advanced Placement Language class, these written responses are great opportunities to practice making argumentative claims. To help, at the end of each school year, The Learning Network publishes a roundup of all its prompts, separated into questions for narrative and personal writing and questions for debate and persuasive writing. Here is the collection from the 2025-26 school year.
In this context, I have students practice more specific writing skills that align with their analyses of the text. For example, after looking at the use of tone in a Times article, students used the same tone in their responses to the Student Opinion forum. In other assignments, I asked them to use qualifications in their claims or to practice using different sentence types.
I also scaffold to support students’ development of rhetorical analysis skills. When we were practicing “SPACECAT” analysis — Speaker, Purpose, Audience, Context, Exigency, Choices, Appeals, Tone — students analyzed the linked Times article using this rubric:
-
Read the articles that are linked in the prompt and identify a rhetorical appeal in one of them. Record a quotation of up to one paragraph of text.
-
Answer the following questions:
— Who is the speaker?
— What is the purpose?
— What is the audience?
— What is the context?
— What is the exigence?
I link other A.P. Language skills to Student Opinion prompts in similar ways. For example, students analyzed the structure of an article, identifying two elements of the author’s line of reasoning, and then used a strong transition word to describe their connection. During review before an exam, I selected a few skills on which students needed more work and crafted specific prompts linked to them, such as:
Skill 7.B — Syntax and Sentence Relationships
-
Identify two sentences with multiple clauses.
-
How are the clauses arranged (independent or dependent)?
-
What relationship between ideas does this structure show (contrast, cause, emphasis, condition, etc.)?
These kinds of exercises can be easily adapted to a variety of standards and skill levels.
Celebrate student voices, and show them that adults care
Later, when Times editors published a collection of teenage voices on the topic in “What Teenagers Are Saying About the Killings in Minneapolis,” seven students from our school were featured.
Students said that the experience made them realize that adults actually cared about what young people thought, and that their voices mattered in the world.
Many students wrote about feeling “deeply troubled” and their “fear that we have finally fallen off the edge of the cliff that was protecting us from a deep, dark period of democratic backsliding.” Others described having “more faith now in my country than I’ve had in a while, seeing communities come together.”
One student said, “I am grateful for these conversations, because it helps myself and others feel less alone, gives me the ability to process the information and learn new perspectives.”
As students around the country (including at my school) walked out in protest of immigration enforcement actions, the experience of participating in the Learning Network forum allowed the teenagers in my class to exercise moral leadership through writing. Their words inspired discussions across the school, which shared their writing on social media. “Knowing these bright, young souls will be out in the world some day gives me so much hope for humanity,” a colleague told me.
But it wasn’t just the Minnesota forum; my students’ posts appeared on more than a dozen of these Times roundups last school year. When a student wrote about how she would redesign math instruction, her math teacher read her featured comment and came to her to discuss it. Another student responded to a prompt about “day in the life” videos with her experience of chronic illness. It would be one thing for her to write about that in her journal or in an assignment for me to read. But it’s another thing entirely for her words “I just want people who also have chronic illness to feel less alone” to appear in the newspaper of record.
When my students’ writing is chosen, I send a note to their families and teachers. I also post printouts of all featured student comments on a bulletin board in my class. In course reflections, students often mention Times publication as the thing they are most proud of. I appreciate deeply that a simple classroom assignment can provide students with an international audience for their writing, giving it an opportunity to live in the world.
One student who had an up-and-down year in my class came to me the day after her writing appeared in the Current Events Conversation column and asked if I thought she should apply to be an editor of our student newspaper. Since then, she has written two articles and is planning to take advanced journalism classes next year.
Create discussion prompts for your own contexts
For the last few years, I have built a regular activity modeled on the Student Opinion forums for my school’s online student newspaper, The Blue and White.
Each time we release a new batch of articles, I write discussion prompts based on as many of them as possible. I give students a choice of which articles to respond to, and I also share these prompts with my colleagues in the English department. (The prompts make an easy “sub plan” for when anyone is out sick.)
Here are a few examples from last school year. I followed the model of the Learning Network prompts by inviting students to share their opinions as well as relevant personal stories and anecdotes:
-
Read “Student Athletes, You are Not Alone.” Do you agree with the perspectives shared in this article? How has your participation in athletics affected your schoolwork and mental health? What are ways that you think teachers, coaches and students can support student athletes’ mental health?
-
Read “The Rising Standards of College Applications.” What did you learn? Do you agree with the perspectives shared about the college process? If you are participating in the college process, or anticipate doing so, what are your feelings and attitudes about college selectivity?
-
Read “A.F.S. and SEPTA Cuts.” Do you ride SEPTA? Did you follow the news about the proposed and rolled-back SEPTA cuts? How have changes to SEPTA service affected your commute to school? What is your commute like?
Prompting students to write comments creates a sense of community engagement. On the day that the latest edition is published, all of my classes are reading and responding to the newspaper, clicking links and talking with one another about articles.
I have appreciated the moments of positive connection that emerge, like when a ninth grader responded to an article by a senior about live music with a comment that praised how the piece “beautifully illustrates the sense of surrealness that happens when experiencing live music.” The commenter added that seeing Sabrina Carpenter and Gracie Abrams perform were “two of the best nights of my life.”
After one student wrote an article calling on Democrats to “fight fire with fire” by participating in gerrymandering, another student responded with respectful disagreement. The author then returned to the conversation, elaborating on his perspective.
As on The Learning Network, our comment sections thus become a moderated space for civil discourse and debate about issues that matter to students. I’ve seen the benefits of bringing those connections in a smaller way to The Blue and White. In response to an article about the killing of Charlie Kirk, many students described their reactions to the news and their feelings about Mr. Kirk. One student shared that her mother was on Mr. Kirk’s Professor Watchlist website and described the “pain” of hearing “those around me speak so highly of a man that I know targeted my family.”
Last spring, I turned over the prompt writing to students. They created a comment policy using the Times guidelines as a model. As you can see in these prompts from our current edition created by a junior and a senior, my students are learning to take ownership of the conditions and content of civil discourse at our school.
